In George Galloway’s Love-Hate Realtionship with the Media, is Bradford just a Gooseberry?

It’s been quite a week for George Galloway, MP for Bradford West, and my Member of Parliament. Much has been written about him, with over 2000 new articles appearing on Google on 20th August, the day he discussed the claims made by two women in Sweden against Wikileaks founder, Julian Assange. This blog post won’t deal with that. Better people than me have written about it and the fallout is yet to come anywhere near settling.

What this post will cover is Mr Galloway’s time as MP for Bradford West and what he’s done for Bradford.

My last post was written after Mr Galloway said he felt sorry for me because I’d prefer to see him in Bradford talking about Bradford than in Manchester talking about Burma. This time, I’m writing after Mr Galloway called me “an internet stalker”, presumably in response to the two tweets I sent re Bradford / Burma and writing that post. The conversation can be seen to the side but I did get one excellent piece of advice from Mr Galloway.

In my last blog, I asked if Mr Galloway had been more prolific and outspoken about foreign issues than those which directly affect Bradford West’s population, and, especially, what has he done to improve Bradford. When these questions were directed to him (not directly by me), his replies were, erm, confused. He said, “I’m not a local councilor” – which suggests to me that he doesn’t see his role as being, at least in a large part, improving the city (excepting the fact that Bradford West would be better if the country and the world were better). He also suggested that his record on speaking up for Bradford could be checked with a quick Google search. So, that’s what I did.

In putting his name forward for the Bradford West seat, Mr Galloway campaigned on a number of issues, international, national and domestic. The latter included Bradford’s unemployment (particularly youth unemployment), the city centre (including Westfield and the Odeon) and education. On a number of occasions, he put these three issues front and centre of his campaign (so these cannot solely be the responsibility of the council and councillors). He told The Daily Politics that he would “regularly” speak about such issues in the media and be “responsible for projecting solutions to those problems in the weeks and months ahead”. I saw this as Mr Galloway’s strength from the start: I voted for him because of his ability to get into the public eye and believed, as I still do, that if used and harnessed correctly, his relationship with the media can be a great source of power and a great driver for Bradford. So, how’s he doing?

George Galloway suggested his record of getting Bradford into the media and his work for Bradford could be shown with a simple Google search. I searched from 29 March to 19 August (Google News – sorted by relevance). This threw up about 8050 results and I recorded the topic of the first 50, which fell into 28 categories. Of these, Mr Galloway had being written about more than once on 6 occasions. If Google is a good barometer, Mr Galloway is most widely discussed in reference to:

By-election victory (inc Labour’s / Milliband’s response) – 8 times
Personal comments made about him (biography / opinion) – 8 times
His return to Parliament – 4 times
Gay rights – 3 times
Suggestions he’d converted to Islam – 3 times
Being banned from traveling to Canada – twice

With the exception of the by-election victory, which tended to name him before or instead of Bradford West at the head), no topic concerning Bradford solely, such as education, unemployment and the city centre, his three key areas for improving Bradford, appear more than once. Indeed, if we look at these multiple references, 5 out of 6 are, pretty much, about him and he is the main or sole focus of them (sometimes in conjunction with, but with him as the main focus over, Bradford, his party or his policies). The topics he was noted for in those first 50 did include some stories on Bradford: he is noted in a story on Bradford’s youth unemployment once; investing in Bradford once; calling for Imdad Hussain (Bradford councilor) to resign once.

What this shows is that Mr Galloway is good at getting in the news, is good at getting column inches and is good at getting the media to report stories in which he is involved. What there isn’t the evidence for is that Mr Galloway is good at getting Bradford in the media spotlight. Even with, arguably, the most high profile of backbench MPs, Bradford’s not getting in the papers. Mr Galloway’s biggest selling point, for me, was his profile and his relationship, however, interesting, with the media, and he’s not using it for the good of Bradford.

But how does he do when it comes to local news? I used the same parameters as above when searching the Telegraph & Argus website. The findings were:

Westfield – 4 times
Youth unemployment – 4 times
Working with Bradford Council – 3 times
Retail in the city centre – 3 times
Death of Marsha Singh – 3 times
Bradford Bulls in administration – 3 times
Making negative comments about Bradford – twice
Closure of Thomas Cook – twice
By-election victory – twice
NHS in Bradford – twice

Mr Galloway is much better at putting his points across in the local media, with a number of his key areas being written about more than once. It’s good that he understands the problems facing Bradford, but most of the stories were him being asked to comment, rather than proactively addressing a problem and getting the issue pushed into the newspaper. An exception to this was Respect’s work on improving education within the authority. However, it’s disappointing that the paper gets a quote from him rather than a story. Where are the headlines “Galloway demands X” or “MP solves Y”? Also, the majority of stories are very negative, with Mr Galloway talking the city down. Bad news, of course, sells better, so I can understand why such stories are more prevalent; however, I hope he talks us up better to potential investors.

Finally, I searched Yorkshire’s national newspaper, the Leeds based Yorkshire Post (using the same parameters as before).

By-election victory (inc Labour’s / Milliband’s response) – 11 times
Elected Mayor for Bradford – 6 times
Local elections – 5 times
Respect Party in the North – twice
Westfield – twice
Odeon – twice
Death of Marsha Singh – twice
Bradford’s economic decline – twice
Unemployment – twice

Here Mr Galloway is better at discussing Bradford and its problems, raising the profile of the city in the county and doing a decent job. However, the greatest number of pieces relate to politics and its workings, rather than the city. Whilst the two do go hand-in-hand, where are his discussions on the bringing jobs to the city, where does he talk up the city in order to attract the investment our near neighbours get in spades, and where does he sell our city?

Overall, Mr Galloway has a knack of getting into the media, but far too often it’s all about him, and the place he’s representing is irrelevant and doesn’t get much of a look in. Time after time, article after article talks about Bradford West only because it’s where Mr Galloway represents, rather than being the focus. Mr Galloway gets into the papers with ease, but it’s time he took Bradford with him. In future, I want to read more about Mr Galloway doing something in Bradford or for Bradford or about Bradford. The media’s to blame to a great extent, to be sure, but such an eloquent, intelligent man as George Galloway has the ability to turn a journalist’s focus away from the man and towards the constituency and the issues.

George Galloway’s biggest strength is his relationship, love and hate, with the media. It’s about time some of that limelight shone on Bradford. If Bradford and Westfield, the Odeon, regeneration, education and unemployment were in the media more, falling from Mr Galloway’s mellifluous lexicon, how could we fail to get something done about those key issues, those problem areas, those stones around Bradford’s neck, which he spoke about before the election?

Mr Galloway’s great at getting in the media – but please can we come too?


About jatkinson1977

I'm in my 30s and married to Sharon, the beautiful woman who keeps me in check. We live in Shipley, just outside Bradford, with our black lab, Nipper. I'm an English teacher in secondary school and, after working as a Teaching & Learning Consultant with the local authority, have returned to the classroom to become a Lead Professional in English at a large comp in Bradford. I'm also trying to become a little more cultured, especially by seeing what culture's right here on my doorstep in Bradford and West Yorkshire (please see my blog, 'Am I Kulchad Yet?'). I've got a third and final blog which is filled with things that, essentially, don't fit into the other two but are interesting enough to share (please see my blog, 'Things That Occur To Me').
This entry was posted in Bradford, George Galloway, Media, Politics and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to In George Galloway’s Love-Hate Realtionship with the Media, is Bradford just a Gooseberry?

  1. A pretty fair appraisal, although there are obviously limitations on using Google for this sort of thing. It’s also worth checking

    Out of 12 written questions:
    2 have been on purely international issues,
    5 on national issues with little local relevance
    3 on issues with some relevance to Bradford
    2 directly about Bradford (unemployment and Bradford Bulls).

    He’s also asked 2 questions in the house, 1 about international issues and 1 about education in Bradford. Overall, he’s not entirely forgotten about Bradford West but most of his attention seems to go to other issues. I also hear from friends that he’s very bad at replying to correspondence from constituents.


  2. Pingback: Will it take a Cannon to fire Galloway? | Things that Occur to Me

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s