A Tale of Two Cities: Bradford 2012

I love living in Bradford. When I tell people that, often I get a quizzical look, a pitying look or eyes rolled up as they struggle to recall the Bradford I’m talking about because it can’t be that Bradford that they’re thinking of. That’s fine. If you read my posts on Am I Kulchad Yet? and most of the posts here thus far, you’ll see that there’s loads going on, that there are tons of positives and that you don’t have to look too hard to find something fun, interesting and lively to do. Of course, the vast majority of the people are proper Yorkshire folk: kind, friendly and welcoming.

However, the more I’ve tried to speak up for Bradford, even sell it, the more disappointed I’ve become with the people in charge, the movers & shakers, the people who should be driving our city forward rather than over it. A great example of this is what I saw today: A Tale of Two Cities.

The first city I saw today was great. Africa Express, a musical collective, turned up with very little notice, split into groups and simultaneously played to audiences across the city. I was in the wonderful CityPark. It was alive with fountains, fun, laughter, dancing and music. It was alive. I loved being so lucky that I had the day off and could go down and experience it.

The second city was dying. From the station to CityPark and back again, I walked past countless closed shops, unloved buildings, examples of stalled regeneration and pawn shops, pound shops & pay day loan shops. It was awful! The city centre away from CityPark and the West End is slowly falling back into the ground.

What’s most distressing is that this hasn’t happened because of the recent economic turmoil: Bradford hasn’t suffered from this recession… because economists agree we haven’t got over the last one yet. I’m a big fan of Bill Bryson who certainly isn’t a fan of Bradford. In Notes from a Small Island, he talked about the empty shops, the dead city centre, the depressing depression. He wrote that in 1995. Things haven’t got better since.

I also read the Ouseley Report, put out as Bradford 2020, and created to understand the reasons behind the 2001 Bradford Riots and ensure lessons were learnt so that it doesn’t happen again. A couple of snippets:

2.5.1 General
The overall public image of Bradford is a poor one and negative media headlines reinforce stereotyping.
2.5.3 Communication
Institutions are not communicating effectively. There is a need for a community-wide newspaper. Not enough use is made of communicating through local and specialist radio that can reach different cultural and faith communities.
2.5.4 Divisions
Bradford District is divided. Inner City Bradford is seen as Muslim dominant and the rest of the District does not see itself as being part of the Bradford identity.
2.5.8 Deprivation and competition
Regeneration processes force communities and neighbourhoods to bid against each other for scarce resources and this creates divisions and resentments.
Regeneration processes require communities and neighbourhoods to compete on “deprivation – deficit models” which, in effect, means that to succeed requires arguing that your area is more deprived and dreadful than the next. This is regarded as negative and reinforces low esteem.
Regeneration may be happening but “we can’t see the benefits”.
2.5.11 Racial discrimination and the labour market
High unemployment levels and racial discrimination in the labour market contribute to many of the problems facing young people of all backgrounds.
2.5.12 Local economy
City pride and civic leadership are pre-requisites for the regeneration of the Bradford District. Pride left when the wealth left and Bradford’s town planners do not go out of their way to help businesses and job creators. Lack of civic pride is reflected in litter-strewn streets and laybys.
The town centre is deemed unfashionable and has insufficient attractions for those outside the City and many young people go elsewhere.
City Hall bureaucracy is frightening away potential investors.
Transport is a huge handicap as there is no central gateway route into the City. Litterstrewn roads and dirty streets discourage potential investors

Remember, this was written in 2001 after the Bradford Riots. How much has changed since then?

In 1995, Bill Bryson said shops are closed, the city centre is dead… and nothing has changed. In 2001, Lord Ouesely said there was little regeneration, high unemployment, poorly skilled young people and a lack of civic pride… and nothing has changed.

I can’t do a lot. What I can do is try to make sure that the people who need to be reminded of this are reminded of it. I’ve already tried to take George Galloway, MP for Bradford West, to task on his record for getting Bradford into the media. I got a lot of people reading my blog and got many people talking about Bradford. I hope that Mr Galloway and the Respect Party in Bradford have thought a little more about Bradford since that. I’m going to keep on at them, reminding our MPs, councillors and governments that we really need help. There are loads of people in Bradford doing great things in Bradford, but they can’t do it alone and they need City Hall, Parliament, Whitehall and lots of other people to do something too. I don’t want to pick on Bradford, to do anything more to talk it down. I want to make Bradford better and I really don’t know how to do it except for asking awkward questions of the right people. I’ll be using a different, more negative, Twitterfeed to try and engage people – Angry from Bradford or @BD_Angry. Please follow if you’d like to keep up to date and send me any messages.

Bradford gets forgotten by the wider world. I want to remind the people who control our destiny that we’re here and we’re not getting a fair crack of the whip.


About jatkinson1977

I'm in my 30s and married to Sharon, the beautiful woman who keeps me in check. We live in Shipley, just outside Bradford, with our black lab, Nipper. I'm an English teacher in secondary school and, after working as a Teaching & Learning Consultant with the local authority, have returned to the classroom to become a Lead Professional in English at a large comp in Bradford. I'm also trying to become a little more cultured, especially by seeing what culture's right here on my doorstep in Bradford and West Yorkshire (please see my blog, 'Am I Kulchad Yet?'). I've got a third and final blog which is filled with things that, essentially, don't fit into the other two but are interesting enough to share (please see my blog, 'Things That Occur To Me').
This entry was posted in Bradford, Council, Councillors, Local Government, Politics, Regeneration and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to A Tale of Two Cities: Bradford 2012

  1. Pat Manning says:

    Excellent post. I’ve lived in Bingley for 28 yrs now. Got my degree at Bfd College when the pubs and clubs were buzzing. When there was still a department store. When Bradford Festival lasted two and a half weeks and was truly inclusive. When Manningham had a large student population. Bradford now is truly depressing. I know much shopping is done online but if my wife and I want to go shopping its Leeds we go to. Bradford needs a vision but I don’t know where it’s coming from


  2. Tom says:

    Yeh, really good summing up of how I feel about Bradford. I really really like the city and it also just depresses me so much too. There’s so much good stuff going on in the city and there’s lot of interesting places to go and things to do, but then again – the city is just dead on a night, it never feels like a particularly nice place to walk around and its got one big image problem which means that most of my friends or family (who are from Leeds, like I am originally) would seldom consider visiting the place.

    When I walk around at night, and see barely anyone in the streets except people up to no good – and the boarded up shops – I totally see where they’re coming from… but on a sunny day, when I see City Park packed to the rafters, loads of beautiful buildings and think of all the different places to go, I think they’re misguided fools!

    Started the Bradfordia blog – because I thought there was a lot to celebrate about the city and a lot of unmet potential that needs to be realised. I thought (probably less so now) that people are either far too negative about the city, or some people are too positive and turn a blind eye to all the issues facing the city. But I have learned there are a lot of people out there who genuinely care about the city and want to see it get better.

    There are lots of ideas for how the city can improve and be a better place – but I can’t see many of them coming to fruition in the current economic climate and with this government’s austerity.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s